Campaigning Doesn’t Work?

Here is another post with insights from a CHQ team member centered around a study that was released last September. The authors of the study used evidence from field experiments to highlight campaign contact in elections. CHQ Campaign Director, Walter Haynie, delivers some great takeaways in his blog post.

I hope you’ll keep reading.

Nicole Schlinger, President of Campaign Headquarters


A lot of buzz has been generated by the recent study on the persuasive effects of campaign contact, authored by UC Berkeley political scientist, Joshua Kalla and Stanford professor David Broockman. If you haven’t seen it, here is the full 166 page study including data on 49 field experiments. Below is a more lunch-time digestible summary.

The media went nuts on this one, with headlines like, “The End of Political Campaigns As We Know Them?” and “Traditional Campaign Tactics Are Basically A Waste Of Time.”  Not surprisingly, the headlines ignore large swaths of the authors’ findings: voter contact works to persuade voters, but only when it’s done right.  

Broockman and Kalla argue that primaries and ballot measures are where persuasion tactics work best.


“We find campaigns are able to have meaningful persuasive effects in primary and ballot measure campaigns, when partisan cues are not present … We see clear significant effects in both these election types.”

The reason, they suggest, is that it is difficult to persuade someone to vote against party cues. Big surprise there. It is therefore relatively much easier to persuade voters toward your candidate or ballot measure when party cues are not present.

Despite the headlines, the study does not assume that voter contact efforts don’t matter in general elections, only that persuasive efforts in general elections do not measurably convince voters to step across party lines. The authors suggest the more significant impacts of campaigns during general elections are to:


“reinforce the political orientations of voters, and mobilize them to vote rather than convert large segments of the population to new ways of thinking… Campaigns clearly can influence whether voters bother to vote at all. Indeed, another implication of our results is that campaigns may underinvest in voter turnout efforts.” 

So what’s my take-away?

  1. Campaigns will get their best “bang for their buck” by focusing persuasive voter contact spending during races lacking party cues, namely ballot initiatives and primary elections.
  2. Once general election races have started, voter contact dollars are probably best spent on GOTV efforts rather than persuasive ones- mobilize the friends you already have, and get them to the voting booth!
  3. If your campaign relies on persuading voters to reconsider their position, you had better identify persuadable voters early on if you want voter contact efforts to be effective.

Do you agree or disagree with Broockman and Kalla? Is this useful academic research, or left-wing nonsense?

Walter Haynie

Campaign Headquarters, Campaign Director

110 thoughts on “Campaigning Doesn’t Work?”

  1. Pingback: cialis coupons
  2. Pingback: cialis india
  3. Pingback: cialis generic
  4. Pingback: Viagra medication
  5. Pingback: Viagra best buy
  6. Pingback: levitra vs cialis
  7. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  8. Pingback: best otc ed pills
  9. Pingback: best ed medication
  10. Pingback: cialis visa
  11. Pingback: levitra 20mg
  12. Pingback: vardenafil coupon
  13. Pingback: buy vardenafil
  14. Pingback: real money casino
  15. Pingback: casinos
  16. Pingback: real online casino
  17. Pingback: loan online
  18. Pingback: online loans
  19. Pingback: instant loans
  20. Pingback: viagra cost
  21. Pingback: online casino usa
  22. Pingback: new cialis
  23. Pingback: cialis to buy
  24. Pingback: cialis buy
  25. Pingback: cialis internet
  26. Pingback: casino slot
  27. Pingback: casinos
  28. Pingback: viagra generic
  29. Pingback: viagra online
  30. Pingback: viagra prices
  31. Pingback: buy viagra
  32. Pingback: when to buy viagra
  33. Pingback: viagra online usa
  34. Pingback: tadalafil generic
  35. Pingback: viagra canada
  36. Pingback: generic cialis
  37. Pingback: free slots online
  38. Pingback: casino slots
  39. Pingback:
  40. Pingback:
  41. Pingback: Viagra 200mg pills
  42. Pingback: cialis website
  43. Pingback: Viagra 200 mg cost
  44. Pingback: Viagra 130 mg otc
  45. Pingback: viagra pills
  46. Pingback: Viagra 150mg nz
  47. Pingback: Viagra 130mg uk
  48. Pingback: Cialis 40mg cheap
  49. Pingback: Cialis 20 mg otc
  50. Pingback: Cialis 10mg cheap
  51. Pingback: cialis pills
  52. Pingback: online viagra
  53. Pingback:
  54. Pingback: cheap cialis
  55. Pingback:
  56. Pingback:
  57. Pingback: online viagra
  58. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  59. Pingback: viagra online
  60. Pingback: sildenafil

Comments are closed.